Take Two

Uploaded 12 May 2011 — 12 favorites
Spotlight This! Enter Shoot Out
Login Required

To add items to your favorites you must login.

Already have a JPG account?

Login

Need to create a JPG account?

Signup
Cancel
JPG+ Required

Collections are a JPG+ feature. You must be a JPG+ member to create new collections and to add photos to collections.

Sign up for JPG+ to start using collections now!

© Deborah Downes
Views 42
Likes 0
Favorites 11
Comments 12
Would you like to also give a props comment to the photographer?
All dislikes require a comment. Please tell us why you do not like this photo.

More of Deborah Downes's Photos

  • Two and Two
  • Take Two
  • Roman Splash
  • In a Blooming Tuscan Field

Photo license: © All rights reserved

This morning I received an email from our dear friend Regenia. She didn't want to hurt my feelings by suggesting I crop out the space to the left of this tree shown in the image I posted earlier. As I told her, I'm all for constructive feedback. That's why I'm on JPG, as well as to share images I love with my JPG friends and all those into photography. As I framed this shot, I thought about doing what Regenia advised, but was attracted to the clouds and shadows to the left of the tree. Later, when I looked at an enlarged version of my original shot, I liked the otherworldly look and feel of it. I love the intimacy of this adaption, but still find I'm most drawn to the other image. Would love your feedback. Thanks so much Regenia for contacting me:)

12 responses

  • Alexis - Now on Flickr

    Alexis - Now on Flickr gave props (12 May 2011):

    Wonderful, iconic image. Personally I agree with Regenia, I find this version more satisfying

  • Patty Gross

    Patty Gross (Deleted) gave props (12 May 2011):

    I don't try to analyze it too much, but I prefer the original photograph. I enjoyed the vastness of the landscape and those wonderful clouds looming overhead. I did ask my husband his opinion, without telling any of the details at all, and he prefers the original photograph (he is a very good professional artist). I believe beauty really is in the eye of the beholder, and we all see things in a different manner. That's what makes photography/art so special and beautiful. Great photo either way, Deborah, I just happen to prefer to first scene.

  • Regenia Brabham

    Regenia Brabham gave props (12 May 2011):

    And as I knew I would...I love both versions for different reasons. Thank you Deborah for letting me see it this way too. I

  • Susan Littlefield

    Susan Littlefield   gave props (12 May 2011):

    I do like the clouds in the other image, but love the intimacy in this one. Also, this one seems to capture that lovely background more clearly.

  • Richard Knight

    Richard Knight gave props (12 May 2011):

    This illustrates a story, whereas the other is a "scene." Each is wonderful in its own way. Classic, too.

  • Joy B

    Joy B gave props (12 May 2011):

    RIchard is right! They are just different! However I find this version more pleasing to my eyes!

  • Donald Garrett

    Donald Garrett   gave props (12 May 2011):

    Here's my take on this: I perceive this one as a simple portrait with a gorgeous Italian background and the other shot, the person is simply an object in the landscape.

  • Laurie Search

    Laurie Search gave props (13 May 2011):

    Ooh, I haven't seen the other one yet! But this is beautiful!! Such a wonderful feel to it...I love the tree's shadow...

  • Leslie Hunziker

    Leslie Hunziker   gave props (13 May 2011):

    Donald is right! 2 different scenes completely, but I think I do prefer this one. Somehow, cropping it to this gives it more depth.

  • Debbie Smartt

    Debbie Smartt gave props (14 May 2011):

    I like them both as well!

  • Bruce Miller

    Bruce Miller (Deleted) gave props (23 May 2011):

    I'm with Regenia. I like this one. The subjects, landscape and person, are better seen and more pronounced this way. The other is lovely too but not as nicely framed.

  • Christopher J Chalk

    Christopher J Chalk gave props (25 May 2011):

    A great collaboration between you and Regenia, this is magnificent Ann!

To add your comment, Log in or sign up!

Please Login or Sign Up

You must be logged in to enter photos into JPG Shoot Out contests.
Login or Sign Up